The former Vampire Diaries co-stars were reportedly spotted getting cozy at an L.A. nightclub last weekend.
If you remember, Ben and Paul met on set of The O.C., while Shelley and Phoebe co-starred on The Secret Circle together.
“Paul and Phoebe were 100% romantic,” the source added. “They were across the table from Ben all cozied up on the couch kissing each other. She had her head on his chest.”
Phoebe is now a regular on the spin-off The Originals.
WHAT DO YOU THINK of Paul and Phoebe as a possible couple?