The ladies were joined at the party by Taylor‘s high school BFF Abigail Anderson and Sarah‘s longtime boyfriend Matt Prokop.
“Happy New Year from two high school BFFs. A look at 2008 vs 2014,” Taylor wrote on Instagram.
“New Years with the best of the best ?? @taylorswift13 (I look scared… I think I should be),” Sarah tweeted before adding, “MEREDITH PHOTOBOMBED US @taylorswift13!!!!!”