The 25-year-old Arrow actor was joined by another presenter, actor Kellan Lutz.
Before the big show, Colton revealed that he ran into some clothing issues.
“Just had 2 hilarious wardrobe malfunctions…finally stopped panicking thx to the #MMVA staff! Haha. Here we go @much,” he tweeted.
In case you missed it, check out the full list of winners from the show here.