“Did this just happen?” the 19-year-old Final Five Olympian shared on Twitter. “@carrieunderwood is the sweetest!!”
Carrie replied to Madison‘s tweet, “I’m so glad I finally got to meet you! You are so gorgeous & sweet! Thanks for coming to the show!”
After returning from Rio, where Madison won a team gold medal and individual silver, Madison made an appearance on Today, where her teammates picked Carrie to play Madison in a dream movie about them.