Modern Family's Haley Dunphy Romance Timeline

Something big happened to Modern Family‘s Haley Dunphy on last night’s episode — she got her first marriage proposal!

Fans seemed quite happy that she turned down Rainer Shine’s (Nathan Fillion) proposal and then broke things off, and actress Sarah Hyland had to give props to Nathan for pulling off eight straight pages of dialogue with her for the scene.

JJJ is happy too — we mean, it’s always been Haley and Andy for us.

Want to see who else Haley‘s dated throughout the show’s eight-season run? We’ve got the full list inside!