The 'Stranger Things' Cast Watched 'High School Musical' on Halloween

The cast of Stranger Things did not have a typical Halloween this year!

Stars Caleb McLaughlin, Gaten Matarazzo, Finn Wolfhard, and Noah Schnapp appeared on The Tonight Show last night (November 2) and told Jimmy Fallon all about their October 31 plans.

“We watched High School Musical,” Caleb revealed. “It was weird.”

“We planned on watching a horror movie,” Gaten explained, adding that he grew up watching the HSM franchise with his sister and co do all of the harmonies without even trying.

As for Finn, he thought they would be watching horror movies that night — but couldn’t complain.

“I get a text from Gaten saying we’re gonna watch a bunch of scary movies and I show up and they’re watching High School Musical,” he said. But the movies shaped his life: he only plays basketball because of Zac Efron!

Watch Finn‘s A+ Troy Bolton impression and their unreal dance battle below!