Fashion Faceoff: Elizabeth and James Tulip Dress

Fashion Faceoff: Elizabeth and James Tulip Dress

Shawn Johnson stepped out at the 2009 CMT Music Awards in Elizabeth and James‘s spring-y “Tulip” dress in Nashville, Tenn., earlier this year. The 17-year-old Olympian paired her red carpet look with sparkly gold heels and double dangle earrings.

Isla Fisher graced the red carpet in the same dress at a screening of the documentary Crude earlier this month. The 33-year-old Shopaholic starlet paired her dress with nude heels and Melinda Maria‘s Black Pave Pod Cuff and Mini Pod Bangles.

Who wore Elizabeth and James best -- SHAWN JOHNSON or ISLA FISHER?
Loading ... Loading ...
Like Just Jared Jr. on FB
Photos: Jason Merritt/Getty, Rachel Worth / WENN
Posted to: Fashion Faceoff, Shawn Johnson
  • menna

    that’s an easy one…

  • MaiChi

    Isla of course.
    Shawn looks rather disgusting in it, no offense.

  • nathalia

    it’s not really fair to compare someone tall and thin wish Shawn.. she has a different body

  • Chau

    Shawn’s body is too bulky or stocky, like rectangular. It’s hard to find clothes that flatter her body and make her look feminine. I guess doing gymnastics can stunt your growth or something. =/ Isla is gorgeous!

  • anonymous

    It looks pretty crappy on both of them. It makes Shawn look dumpy and it’s too tight on Isla across the top, or else she’s wearing a strapless push up bra. Either way, her breasts look they are being squished out the top.

  • aury

    omg!! what happen with Shawn? she look’s fat! o.o

  • Matilda

    Sarah Michelle Gellar was first seen wearing this dress before she gave birth to Charlotte Grace.

  • Lucy

    @nathalia: actually, isla’s only about 5’3, so she’s pretty small too! but yeah, she is taller and slimer, and it is a bit unfair.

    personally, i like isla wearing it, i think shawn needed a bra with it, her boobs look a bit saggy lol!! xx