'Claim to Fame' Season 2 Finale: Our Best Guesses For Final 4 Celebrity Relatives Based on Clues & Online Sleuths

“Olivia” – REVEALED WEEK 6

In week six, Olivia found herself in the bottom two in jeopardy of being voted the guesser of the week, and she was in fact voted as such.

However, things didn’t go as she planned as when she guessed Karsyn’s celebrity relative, she got it wrong, meaning that her celebrity relative was now going to be revealed.

While some were guessing she was related to comedian Carrot Top, but the remaining contestants were very shocked to learn that Olivia’ celebrity relative is actually Jenny McCarthy!

She is Jenny‘s niece, Olivia. Back in 2015, Jenny even shared a photo of Olivia, and wrote, “My gorgeous niece Olivia.” Check it out HERE!

All of the Jim Carrey clues pointed straight to the fact that Jenny dated him for five years, from 2005-2010. Other clues leading to Jenny include the “Happy New Year” glasses, as she co-hosts New Year’s Eve in Times Square and the red cross/hospital clue could point to her years of charity work.