'Claim to Fame' Season 2 Finale: Our Best Guesses For Final 4 Celebrity Relatives Based on Clues & Online Sleuths

“Cole” – REVEALED WEEK 5

Just one week after Cole shockingly chose to guess Shayne’s identity (and correctly), he found himself as a major target and the subject of being guessed in episode five.

Clues about Cole’s celebrity relative included a giant slice of swiss cheese as a statue. At the very end of episode 4, it was also revealed by Monay that she was onto him and from the clue wall, picked up a diary and a piano, pointing towards who he is related to, guessing Alicia Keys.

The following week, Monay then revealed that Shayne had said Alicia looked like Cole, and that she had a half-brother who she thinks dated Emma Watson. In another conversation with Cole, Monay said that he shared his ex girlfriend lived in London.

In week five, Karsyn was voted as the guesser and chose to guess Cole’s identity. Her guess was Alicia Keys, and it was correct!

Cole is in fact Alicia‘s younger half-brother Cole Cook, who was linked to Emma Watson in May 2019.